Request an invite

Blog

Carousel or video: which to use for what

By ReadySetPost team ·

A short video and a carousel can carry the same message, but they ask different things of the viewer. A video sets the pace: it plays, and the viewer keeps up or leaves. A carousel hands the pace over: the viewer swipes when ready, goes back, or stops on one slide.

Once you see that difference, choosing between them gets easier.

What a video is good at

  • Movement and process. Kneading, pouring, cutting, assembling, a wall being painted. If the point is how something happens, show it happening.
  • People. A face and a voice build familiarity in a way that text on a slide does not. If customers buy from you partly because of you, be in the video, or at least be heard in it.
  • Feeling. The sound of the espresso machine, a busy Saturday, the reveal at the end of a makeover. Sound and timing carry mood.
  • One simple point. A single tip or answer that can be said in twenty seconds.
  • Meeting new people. Instagram, YouTube and TikTok each have a feed of short videos that shows people accounts they do not follow yet, so a video is often how a stranger first comes across you.

Where video is weak: anything the viewer needs to read, compare or come back to. A price list that flashes by for two seconds helps nobody.

What a carousel is good at

  • Steps and lists. "Five things to check before you buy a used bike", one per slide.
  • Details people need to read. Sizes, ingredients, care instructions, what is included, a menu, a timetable.
  • Comparisons. Before and after, option A next to option B.
  • Things worth keeping. A checklist, a recipe, a packing list. A carousel is easy to return to, and easy to find one slide in.
  • A range. Six new arrivals, four colors, three room layouts.

Where a carousel is weak: movement, mood and voice. It also depends heavily on its first slide. If that slide does not earn the swipe, the rest is never seen.

Three questions that decide it

  1. Does it move? If the interesting part is an action or a change as it happens, make a video.
  2. Does it need reading? If the viewer has to take in words or numbers at their own speed, make a carousel.
  3. Will they want it again later? If it is something to keep and look up, make a carousel.
When to use a carousel or a video
You want toUse
Show how something is madeVideo
Answer one common questionVideo
Introduce yourself or your teamVideo
Show the atmosphere of your placeVideo
Give step by step instructionsCarousel
Compare optionsCarousel
Share a checklist or a recipeCarousel
Show a before and afterCarousel, or a video if the change itself is worth watching
Announce an event with a date, place and priceCarousel, or a video with the details repeated in the caption

Making a carousel that gets swiped

  • The first slide is the hook. A clear title that says what the viewer gets. It follows the same rule as the first second of a video.
  • One idea per slide. Few words, in large type. Check it on a phone held at arm's length.
  • Make the slides a set. The same colors and the same type on every slide, so it reads as one post.
  • Give a reason to continue. Number the steps, or let a sentence run on to the next slide.
  • End with the next step. The last slide says what to do: visit, message, save.

On Instagram a carousel can mix photos and short clips. That is useful when most steps are fine as pictures but one needs to be seen moving.

Use the same idea twice

A good idea usually works in both forms. "Three mistakes when watering houseplants" can be a thirty second video this week and a four slide carousel next month: a title slide and one slide per mistake.

This is not cheating. People who missed the first will see the second, and you get two posts from one piece of thinking. The video can introduce you to people who do not know you, and the carousel is the version they can keep.

If you can only make one

Pick the one you will keep making. If filming is hard for you, a good carousel built from photos you already have beats a video you never get around to. If you are comfortable talking to your phone, a video can be quicker than designing slides.

Start with whichever is easier, keep a steady rhythm, and add the other when you have the first under control. For help choosing that rhythm, see how often a small business should post.

More from the blog